Thursday, March 08, 2007

Iron Chef Mom Challenge




Meredith, over at Like Merchant Ships, emailed me to tell me how much she has enjoyed my new blog. For her though, Aldi Supermarket is a bit of a hike and she believes that she can do just as well by buying the loss leaders at her local grocery stores and planning her menu around the sale options. She decided to offer up a friendly challenge and see who could save the most money, an Aldi Shopper or a Sales Shopper. I told her I was up for the challenge and am excited to see how well we both can do.

The game will begin this Monday and I will be posting my meals each day, but include a daily total for the day versus the weekly totals that I normally do. I will also include some tips for shopping on that particular day, as part of the challenge. Meredith will also be doing the same thing on her blog and I will include a link to her entry too.


Here are the rules of the game:

I will purchase everything from Aldi Supermarket.

Meredith will be doing a freestyle menu with no coupons and only using the grocery sales current from that week. She will not be using any items from her stockpile, only items purchased that week.

A daily breakdown will be given each day. The breakdown will include the menu, recipe, and cost breakdown.

The menu will serve four people. In larger recipes, we will be adjusting the cost to estimate a four person meal, or split the cost if one meal actually will be used in two different ways.

The menu will include a main dish and sides. Desserts and drinks will not be included in this challenge.

Staple ingredients under a ½ cup are “negligible,” for example in the case of flour, sugar, salt or pepper. Otherwise, these will be figured in as price per ounce and multiplied by the number of ounces used.

There will be a wrap-up at the end of the week and you, as readers, can feel free to critique our strategies, or offer up some of your own strategies.

Just for the record, I do want to say that this is just a fun and friendly competition. The idea behind it is not to see who will do better than the other, but more to share techniques for two different ways to shop. Both of these options do not require any coupon cutting and will show you ways that you can plan affordable meals for your family using two other types of techniques.

We are both very excited to be doing this contest and our families are excited to be eating so well this week.

Thanks to Meredith for posing such a great challenge! I hope that it will be as much fun for you as it is for us!

Labels:

12Comments:

Blogger Pleasant View Family
"Hysterical! You are the two women I look to most for frugal shopping techniques, and now you're going to pool your savvy tips together! I tend to shop Aldis & loss leaders, so it will be fun to see the difference!"

at 1:23 PM  

Blogger Heather
"I can't wait to see the outcome. I am a loss-leader shopper for the same reason- Aldi is much further. I do shop quite a bit at a store called Save-A-Lot. It's very similar to Aldi and I get some great deals.
I'm going to post about this and link back to both of you."

at 1:28 PM  

Blogger it's a Mom thing
"AWESOME!!! I can't wait to see who WINS!!!!"

at 1:40 PM  

Blogger amelia
"This is going to be great! I need to get my grocery down to $50 a week. We don't have Aldi in town, and I think Publix, Winn Dixie and SweetBay have horrible sales. I'm left with Walmart. yuk. And hubby doesn't eat much meat. So I'm most curious to study both your methods and learn!!"

at 2:06 PM  

Blogger PeppermintPearl
"What fun!
I love Aldis and I love your menu plans from there. I've used several of your recipes that have been BIG hits with my family."

at 5:16 PM  

Blogger Alexandra
"I shop Save-A-Lot too, and sales at Food Lion. Sadly, no Aldi's nearby to sample. I'll be following the fun. I've linked the competition to my blog."

at 6:53 PM  

Anonymous Tracy Nightingale
"I'm definately excited to see this! Meijer is closer than Aldi (a good 10 minutes closer) so sometimes I just don't want to go that far! This should be fun!
Tracy"

at 8:21 PM  

Blogger Margaret
"Ok, heather pointed me here... what is Aldi???"

at 8:27 PM  

Blogger Amy
"Aldi is just a discount supermarket, much like Save-A-Lot. They do not carry brand name products, just generic products. The pricing is much lower than the regular prices at the supermarket. If you would like the full scoop, I wrote an article about the store here:
http://tinyurl.com/322gu3

By the way, WELCOME :) Please take a look around!!"

at 8:33 PM  

Blogger Nico
"This sounds great! Go Amy! I can't wait to see the all the great recipes and amazing savings."

at 9:06 PM  

Blogger thehomespunheart
"What fun! I'm excited to see the results!"

at 5:46 AM  

Blogger Rose
"Hey Amy! This sounds like fun and I can't wait to see the outcome. Either way, we'll all learn a lot from your experiences and recipes. I have a few thoughts:

This contest is skewed. Aldi doesn't accept coupons anyway (not here at least) so all this rule is doing is preventing Meredith from using coupons.

It doesn't matter, though. You can still win because Aldi's everyday prices are much lower than a store's everyday prices and usually lower than - or comparable to - a sale price.

It depends on what you buy and what you make. If you rely heavily on the frozen and prepared foods (admittedly, much cheaper to buy at Aldi than elsewhere) your cost will be much higher than if you make stuff from scratch. And the scratch stuff is simply the cheapest at Aldi.

There are occasional super buys with loss leaders but Meredith cannot be guaranteed that anything worthwhile will come up during the time specified. It's a gamble.

Okay, I'm putting way too much thought into this. Maybe I just wish I had thought of it first! =) Have fun!"

at 2:02 PM  

I am a frugal hacker
My site was nominated for Hottest Mommy Blogger!
My site was nominated for Best Blog Design!
My site was nominated for Best Parenting Blog!
My site was nominated for Best Food Blog!