Wednesday, February 18, 2009

Notebook Experiments: Can I Make Pretzels Like Auntie Anne's?

Experiment: Can I make pretzels like Auntie Anne's?

Experiment Taken From: Notebook Entry 01.29.09

Materials Needed: Please see maya made for the full instructions.

Results: Remember when I mentioned that I totally failed on a notebook experiment? Well, this is the experiment that I did not end up doing well.

I thought it would be fun (my husband would say ambitious) to make my hubby some heart-shaped pretzels for a special Valentine's Day treat. One of his favorite things in the world is soft pretzels and I thought this would be a wonderful way to show him how much I loved him, particularly during our No Spend Challenge month. I mean, what says I love you more than baking for someone?

The first mistake I made was not using the recipe that maya made had used. I actually used this recipe and used my bread machine to make the dough instead of the stand mixer. The dough was difficult to roll out and kept balling back up together.

After finally maneuvering it into a heart shape, I then had to try and put them in the baking soda solution. My mistake, throwing in too many and leaving them in far too long. When I took them out, I started to wonder if it would have been better not to have put them in the solution.

I'm all like, what in the hay happened to these pretzels?

At this point, I keep pressing on. After mixing dough, shaping dough, dipping dough in baking soda solution, letting dough rise, and getting ready to bake them again there is no way in heck I was going to do that again. And my kitchen was the biggest disaster you have ever seen-flour everywhere, dirty pots and pans, baking soda spilled all over my stove. I was worried, but I was going to wrap up this horrible idea of a project.

Delicious? This picture might be deceiving!

I took the hot pretzels out of the oven. The bottoms were brown, the tops were still doughy. I stuck them back in for two more minutes and melted butter. Yup, another pan! I brushed the butter on top and ran one down to take a picture of it. It actually looked yummy! I gave my husband the first one and he devoured it. He ate a second. Maybe I was a success.

Then I took a bite and I literally spit it on my plate. It tasted like baking soda through and through. Meanwhile, Emily has happily ate almost the entire pretzel and then suddenly looks at me with utter disgust and hands her pretzel back to me. "I no like this, mommy." I think the cinnamon and sugar threw her off from the disgusting taste.

I didn't cry as I surveyed the damage in my kitchen and hurled the poor excuse for pretzels in my trash can. It is the thought that counts, perhaps, but I shall never think this thought again.

Conclusion: I will never ever make pretzels again. I will leave this task to the highly trained people at the mall and I will pay six dollars (or whatever outrageous amount is charged) to have someone else do this for me.

Call me lazy, but some things are better left to the professionals and this is one of those tasks I can't see myself repeating.

If you have made pretzels before, please feel free to share your tips! What has been your biggest cooking disaster?


**********************
Want to join in on the MomAdvice No Spend Challenge? Make sure to add your name to the linky list and read more about our challenge. You can also join our No Spend Challenge Flickr Group and upload your pictures of what you did each day.

To read all the entries on not spending, you can visit our No Spend Challenge category!
********************

I am so excited to open our Notebook Experiments up to everyone and I hope that you will be able to participate this week or in weeks to come! I will be posting this each Wednesday so please mark your calendars if you plan to participate. You can post your entries at any time throughout the week and then leave your entry in the links below.

We have this handy banner that you are more than welcome to use, but it is not a requirement! It is just something you can add to add a little sparkle to your entry.

Rules for Participation:

1. Choose anything from any of our notebook entries (past or present) to do with your family. We have hundreds of bookmarked links of crafts, ways to save money, and organizing ideas.
2. Complete an experiment from the notebook and share about it on your blog or website. We would love to see pictures of what you accomplished or a detailed description of how your projects turned out. Please include a link to this entry, a link to the original posting of the entry (at the original crafster's blog), and (to help us relocate the project) the date or link of the notebook entry where you found it. You can use the same formatting as our entries or you can just include that information in your post in your own unique way!
3. Post a link below. Please include your name or blog name & a fast description of your project. Example- MomAdvice (WHO bread)

I can't wait to see what you create and what you find inspiring!

Labels: ,

ENJOYED THIS POST? SHARE IT WITH OTHERS:

Click to share on StumbleUpon STUMBLE This Click to share on kirtsy Add to KiRTSY Click to share on Mixx Add to MIXX Click to share on DeliciousIt's DELICIOUS

19Comments:

Anonymous Renee Crabtree
"If you have never had them, you MUST try the Amish pretzels at the Farmer's Market! Let's go one of these Saturdays after you no-spend month! You won't be sorry."

at 7:22 AM  

Blogger Marva
"Amy, They look deleicous! i am so sorry that it turned out so badly. Yes, I agree......leave some things to the professionals. I've had those kind of things to happen before, shall we say homemade biscuits?!

Have a great day! Blessings!"

at 7:32 AM  

Blogger Christi
"Amy, I have tried to make homemade soft pretzels several times, and I can't pull it off either. My problem always comes in when I'm trying to shape them - the dough will not stretch & shape.

I WILL try again - and I'll let you know if it works!"

at 8:21 AM  

Blogger Leah
"Amy, my friend had a mix from Auntie Anne's that we used to make soft pretzels with. They actually turned out really well, and were not too difficult to make. I'll see if I can find out where she got the mix from. Love you!

Be not discouraged though! You're a fantastic cook!!"

at 8:27 AM  

Blogger Vanessa
"You can always buy really good, and really cheap, frozen soft pretzels :-)"

at 8:29 AM  

Blogger Rachel
"Aww! It made for a good post though, you see? I've never tried making these, but I've made plenty of other disasters (usually fudge is involved)."

at 8:50 AM  

Anonymous Donna
"Kudos for attempting the pretzels. The thing that scares me is trying to twist them into a pretzel shape. Some things are so much easier packaged....LOL. I buy the frozen pretzels when they are on sale, no fuss, no muss!"

at 9:06 AM  

Blogger mayaluna
"I'm so sorry for the disaster... we've all had them. When the kitchen looks like a tornado hit it, it doesn't seem to matter as much if the recipe was a success. How disappointing it always is when it all goes awry! For the record, I've had dozens of readers, with no pretzel making background, have great results with my recipe... Here's to soft pretzel however and wherever you get them!"

at 9:47 AM  

Blogger Amy
"Maya- Oh you may have just convinced me to give this another shot. I wish I would have used your recipe since it was a tried and true instead of hunting for my own :) You are the best to leave a comment. Thank you!"

at 9:56 AM  

Blogger Rachel
"I'm sorry your pretzels didn't turn out. I know the feeling. I once made bagels for my family, they were edible but really hard and just anything like what I think a good bagel should be...and it was a huge mess, too.

I'm glad you kept your humor. "It is the thought that counts, perhaps, but I shall never think this thought again." You crack me up!"

at 10:01 AM  

Anonymous Shannon Zimmerman
"Consider treating yourself to an authentic Auntie Anne's pretzel at home with our Make-Your-Own Pretzel Kit! The kit allows you to mix, twist and bake 10 Original or Cinammon Sugar pretzels. It includes all of the dry ingredients, along with step-by-step instructions. All that's needed is vegetable oil, non-stick spray, and butter for a much simpler process! Kits can be purchased at an Auntie Anne's store location or online, http://www.shopauntieannes.com/.

Enjoy!
Shannon Zimmerman
Senior PR Specialist
Auntie Anne's, Inc."

at 10:17 AM  

Blogger Garnet
"I just tried these for the first time recently too. The dough is super stretchy and hard to work with. I think that is just the nature of the beast. As a result, my pretzels turned out a lot thicker than I would have hoped for and when I baked them for the recommended time, they were still doughy in the middle. Oops. But once I adjusted the cooking time, they were great! I think the key is to just barely dip it in the baking soda solution. One at a time and just enough to get it wet. Don't give up yet. You can totally do this."

at 10:22 AM  

Blogger Ginger Jager
"Oh man, if only that had worked. I LOVE those pretzels. I cannot resist them. My lifelong goal is to perefct a lemon meringue pie. Pie crusts intimidate me, but that pie is my husband's absolute favorite dessert and his mom makes a perfect pie. So you can see my problem. I have made 2 in my life--the first was pathetic, the second was not bad. But not good."

at 10:31 AM  

Blogger junglewife
"I've made a recipe similar to this before. It does take a long time to shape the pretzels. Usually I just roll out the dough into "logs" and then cut them into pretzel "sticks" rather than shaping them. Much easier and just as tasty. Also, I shape/make/cut them all and then dip them one at a time into the baking soda solution. Also I don't let them rise again after putting them in the baking soda - just straight into the oven they go. You should try it again. They're tasty!"

at 10:47 AM  

Blogger Your Frugal Friend, Niki
"Gosh I feel your pain! I attempted to do this once before too and it was a major flop. They looked great but tasted awful. The texture was so wrong!

Have you ever had Amish pretzels at a market before? They are heaven, dipped in butter!

I thought I loved Auntie Anne's til I had them!


:)"

at 2:49 PM  

Blogger Amy
"I have never ate an Amish pretzel so I am definitely going to have to try those. Thanks for that recommendation!

Thanks everyone for making me feel better- maybe I won't give up on pretzels just yet :) It will be awhile though before I try it again, I can say that :)"

at 5:51 PM  

Anonymous The Happy Housewife
"I have had great success with homemade pretzels, and they weren't that hard. One problem that you had was the baking soda solution. I just dip mine in, I don't let them sit. I have made whole wheat dough and white and they both turned out great. I'll find the recipe and send it to you. I think you should try it again as it really can be done.
Toni"

at 12:44 PM  

Anonymous Kristie McNealy
"I made cinnamon sugar pretzels for our home school Valentines Day party this week. I use my regular bread dough. After the first rise, I punch it down and let it rest 10 minutes. Then I roll them and twist. Once you have a batch ready (4 fit in my pan), you boil them for 30 seconds in baking soda and water. Then bake for 12-15 minutes. No need for a second rise. They are really yummy!"

at 5:27 PM  

Blogger mama k
"oh no! I have made them several times with great results. However, I had a similar experience recently where I tried a new recipe and overdid the baking soda thing. I need to find the old recipe and make those again."

at 12:47 PM  

I am a frugal hacker